(Kara DioGuardi)

Surprise, surprise
I told you lies
I thought the truth would set you free

Surprise, surprise
It isn’t all as it seems
But who knew you’d wake up from your dreams
If I told you myself I could have saved you the hell
Now look who’s sorry
God, I’m so sorry
It was never the right time
I guess it’s do or die

Just when you think you’ve got me figured out
Just when you think you know me well
Baby you’ve barely even broke the ice
My river runs wide
You’re not inside
But you’re closer than you were

Tonight, I’m a chameleon
And every spot’s hiding my scars
But I will survive
'Cause I’ll only let you in
When I can be sure of who you are
And you can call it a game
But it’s me playing safe
And God I’m so sorry
I’m just so sorry
What can I say
It’s hard trying to stay alive

Just when you think you’ve got me figured out
Just when you think you know me well
Baby you’ve barely even broke the ice
My river runs wide
You’re not inside
But you’re closer than you were
You were
Tonight, tonight, tonight

And it’s in your eyes
That is all or nothing
What I can’t disguise
Is that you’re on to something
I’ll let myself go
Will you still want me
Will I be enough to fill up that harmed space
’Cause what if you walk away

Just when you think you’ve got me figured out
Just when you think you know me well
Baby, you’ve barely even broke the ice
My river runs wide
You’re not inside
But you’re closer than you were
You were
Tonight, tonight, tonight
Just when you think you’ve got me figured out
Just when you think you’ve got me figured out
Surprise, surprise